Blake Lively
In 2011, DiCaprio shocked the world by dating Lively for a few months. This was a complete break from type because he usually dated supermodels. Lively is a beautiful woman but the actress has a girl-next-door appearance. Meanwhile, it was the first time that he was with somebody from his industry.

It’s hard to imagine the pair together now because Lively has a wholesome marriage to Ryan Reynolds. The pair are raising a happy family and appear to be one of Hollywood’s most functional couples. We don’t know what she was thinking because everybody knew DiCaprio’s reputation (via Glamour).